iSport | For the Fans, by the Fans

Tuesday
May 22nd
Text size
  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home Cricket IPL Muddled and Rudderless KKR loses again

Muddled and Rudderless KKR loses again

E-mail Print PDF
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 

From the iSport Cricket Paddock: Ardent KKR fan and iSporter Hirok Banerjee is not a happy man. Read his post-match analysis of the MI vs KKR match here.

Sourav-Ganguly-India-Australia-1st-Test-Day-5_1332877

When a lot of things go into thinking about simple things, then basics are compromised and things get unnecessarily complicated. The innings of the Knight Riders resembled that of a ship which knew where it wanted to go but lost its way – with a captain who seems to have no idea how to read a compass.

The game of T20 is one which requires being constantly aggressive at one end while ensuring that hara-kiri is not committed on the other. This is not a game for solid, steady, sedate batting. This is not a game for puritans. This is a game where a defensive mindset almost invariably will ensure defeat. Ganguly’s emphasis on keeping wickets intact for the first half of the innings does have merit. But the underlying assumption on that would be that the team scores at a brisk pace during the middle overs finally leading to an insurmountable assault in the slog overs. Unfortunately, the fear of losing crucial batsmen has bogged down Ganguly so much that Chris Gayle played an innings which appeared to have been played by his shadow. Maybe, he left his ‘mongoose’ at Jamaica.

The Knights made two interesting changes which defied all logic and thought. They dropped Hodge and Tiwary and got in Mandeep Singh and Harpreet Singh. In a team, where there is a dearth of stroke-players, the exclusion of Tiwary is surprising, considering only him having shown some sort of ability to hit. With a start of 42 without loss after 6 overs, the expectation would be that someone would cut loose. Instead we were subjected to another round of absolutely torrid batting where fulltosses were hit straight to fielders and no innovation was seen in the batting.

The less said about the Riders’ bowling, the better. While Mumbai showed how to come up with yorkers and slower deliveries repeatedly, the Knights bowled short and wide and deserved every bit of the treatment meted out by Tendulkar and Co. It is time that Ishant Sharma understood that fast bowling is as much about brains as about brawns. Strangely, the bowling coach of KKR has been one of the best exponents of the art of fast bowling in world cricket. Maybe, Ganguly can place a request to Modi to allow Wasim to take the field in place of Ishant. The result would assuredly be many times better!

155 were never enough from the beginning. It needed two blitzy innings. And that was what happened. Tendulkar, possibly in the form of his life, ensured that Mumbai came within striking distance from where it would just be a matter of sensible batting. Sachin paced his innings to perfection. He slapped out Ishant whenever it was pitched short, which was about all the time, and one straight drive in the second over and three front-foot pulls thereafter showed why he is considered one of the greatest ever to stand with a willow in his hand. 

There was a time in the middle overs when Kartik and Mathews squeezed Mumbai and Kartik did have the chance of turning the match when the score read 70 for 1. He dropped the match – a simple caught and bowled of Sachin. With 80 still required off the last 10 overs, it could have gone down the wire. 

KKR is more or less out of the reckoning for a semi-final berth, if ever they had a chance. It’s a shame, that India’s most successful captain finally has fallen prey to the very thing he taught his team to denounce – the fear of defeat. Adios Sourav! IPL was never meant to be for you.


AddThis Social Bookmark Button
Comments (4)add comment

a guest said:

0
...
Seeing Ganguly fumble these days will make anybody wonder whether he was ever a good captain or was it just sheer luck and Dravid. Playing untested youngsters is fine and adds some x factor to an otherwise predictable and dull side, but so far in 3 versions of IPL, good youngsters have performed only when they were given opportunity at the top and told to attack. Not at no. 5 or 6. Even Tiwari flourished while opening. I doubt how much of a gamechanger can a mandeep/harpreet be if they come in at no 5/6. Ganguly can only be accomodated at no. 4 or 5 in this format. One more thing of note in this IPL has been the success of good players from ICL like jhunjhunwala, rayudu, satish etc. KKR roped in the best allrounder from ICL, ganapati vignesh, and doesnt even play him. The only progress I have seen Ganguli make from IPl 1 to 3 is getting out of love with a certain mr. Agarkar. That may just not be enough.
 
March 25, 2010
Votes: +0

a guest said:

0
...
Seeing Ganguly fumble these days will make anybody wonder whether he was ever a good captain or was it just sheer luck and Dravid. Playing untested youngsters is fine and adds some x factor to an otherwise predictable and dull side, but so far in 3 versions of IPL, good youngsters have performed only when they were given opportunity at the top and told to attack. Not at no. 5 or 6. Even Tiwari flourished while opening. I doubt how much of a gamechanger can a mandeep/harpreet be if they come in at no 5/6. Ganguly can only be accomodated at no. 4 or 5 in this format. One more thing of note in this IPL has been the success of good players from ICL like jhunjhunwala, rayudu, satish etc. KKR roped in the best allrounder from ICL, ganapati vignesh, and doesnt even play him. The only progress I have seen Ganguli make from IPl 1 to 3 is getting out of love with a certain mr. Agarkar. That may just not be enough.
 
March 25, 2010
Votes: +0

a guest said:

0
...
@Guest: Could not agree more with you. Thankfully, so far we have not seen Agarkar in action. Ganguly was never a great thinker. He was instinctive and inspirational and he had the fire. Sadly enough, in IPL III, those attributes seem to be missing.
 
March 26, 2010
Votes: +0

a guest said:

0
...
I hope you have mentioned this as Saurav's swansung too early like the countless people who have done so earlier...just wanna repeat that many of them have been made to eat humble pie...just wait till the end of the tournament and then make your signature judgement....KKR got rid of Ishant and that solved half of the problems...Saurav is still one of the best in KKR and the games KKR have won have been driven by his astute captaincy...lets wait n watch
 
March 28, 2010
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Author Profile: Hirok Banerjee

This author has published 27 articles so far. More info about the author is coming soon.

IPL 4 - Team Introductions

royal1Kochi-Tuskers-Kerala-Team-Squaddeccan_chargers_logochennai_super_kings_ipl_logoDelhi-DaredevilsMumbai-Indians-IPL-Logosaharapunewarriors-logo

You Might Also Want To Read

Please login to be able to comment and post articles. If you haven't registered yet, why not register for a free account?

iSport Specials

 

iSport Special: The Joy of Twenty20 Cricket

From the iSport Cricket Pavilion: iSporter Aswath B talks about the Twenty20 (T20) Cricket and how it is widely popular ...

 

My First Marathon

iSporter Alekh Agrawal shares his modest yet enormously moving and inspiring experience as he ran his first full maratho...

 

iSport Special: Foul Play in Fun land

Is Cricket really a Gentlemen's game now? The game has changed a lot since the first ever officially recognized Test mat...

 

iSport Special: A Recap of the Year that Went By - 2011

As the curtains come down on an eventful 2011, it is time to press the rewind button and reflect on the various events t...

 

iSport Special: Vinod Kambli Reopens Match Fixing Pandora Box

From the iSport Cricket Pavilion: Is Messr Vinod Kambli a liar? iSporter Linus Fernandes pens a thought provoking piec...
AddThis Social Bookmark Button